When is a horse not really a horse? This is just one question Daphne Fuller, the middle-aged narrator of Ann Patchett’s ebullient novel, asks herself after a chance encounter with her former stepfather in New York’s Metropolitan Museum. A teacher at a private school, Daphne barely recalls editor Eddie Triplett’s brief marriage to her mother and the car accident that derailed her moment of childhood happiness. As they forge a fresh intimacy, she’s swept up in a whirl of Manhattan elites, publishing lore, a half-remembered tragedy, and a story-within-a-story starring a chestnut mare. With characteristic precision, Patchett pries apart myths of…

Read the full article at TIME.COM